How Investors Are Using F&O To Hedge Their Portfolios Without Getting Fooled By The Low VIX?

The stock market is behaving strangely right now. We have all seen the big, choppy swings and sharp drops, like the Nifty 50 falling over 1,300 points in just three days recently. But if you look at the market's Fear Gauge, the India VIX, it is surprisingly calm, sitting low around 12.16.

This is a major disconnect. It is like a fire alarm that is not ringing even though there's smoke in the room. This is the exact reason many smart investors are turning to Futures and Options (F&O). A low VIX means that "insurance" for your portfolio is cheap, and they are using this chance to buy protection before real panic sets in and insurance becomes expensive.

"From our desk's perspective, the current market environment is a textbook example of a volatility disconnect. We are seeing significant 'under the hood' churn, yet the India VIX remains stubbornly low. This suggests a dangerous level of complacency. Sophisticated investors are not asking 'if' they should hedge, but 'how.' They are actively using this period of low implied volatility to procure portfolio protection at a discount," commented Bhavya Shah, Technical Analyst, StoxBox.

Why Hedge? The Goal is 'Capital Preservation'

For serious investors, F&O is not for gambling; it is for protecting the money you have already made. This goal is called Capital Preservation, a simple idea that means your first priority is not to lose your original investment.

When the market gets shaky, your first instinct might be to sell all your stocks. This is often a bad idea for three main reasons as per Bhavya Shah.

Taxes: If you have held stocks for a long time, selling them means you will get a large tax bill on your profits.

Costs: Selling and then re-buying a large portfolio costs a lot in brokerage fees and other charges.

Bad Timing: You might end up selling a great long-term company just because of a short-term market scare.

Hedging lets you protect your portfolio from a short-term drop without having to sell your long-term investments. Think of it like buying insurance for your portfolio.

How Investors Are Using F&O to Hedge?

Investors are using three main strategies, depending on how bearish they are.

1. The Futures Hedge (When You Are Very Bearish)

Investors who are convinced the market is going down are using a Futures Hedge. They do this by shorting Nifty futures. This works like a seesaw: if the market falls, their stock portfolio loses value, but their short futures position makes a profit, which helps cancel out the loss.

To do this properly, they use a Beta-Hedge. Beta is just a number that shows how jumpy your portfolio is compared to the Nifty.

"If your portfolio has a Beta of 1.2, it means it is 20% more volatile than the Nifty. Investors calculate this number to know exactly how many Nifty futures they need to short to protect their specific portfolio," said Bhavya Shah.

This hedge is a complete lock. If the market goes up, their stocks gain, but the futures lose, wiping out all the profit. You are protected, but you also miss out on any upside.

2. The Protective Put (The 'Insurance' Policy)

This is the most popular strategy for investors who are cautiously optimistic. They want their stocks to go up, but they are worried about a sudden crash.

They buy a Protective Put option, which is exactly like buying insurance. This option gives them the right to sell their holdings at a floor price, no matter how low the market goes.
This insurance costs money, which is called a "premium".

If the market doesn't crash, they lose the premium they paid (which is a small, known loss). But if the market rallies, they get to keep all their profits, minus the small cost of the insurance.

"Investors must differentiate their tools. Shorting Nifty futures is a symmetric hedge. It effectively takes you out of the market, sacrificing all upside to eliminate downside. Buying a protective put, however, is an asymmetric insurance policy. It costs a premium, but it allows you to retain all of your portfolio's upside. The choice depends on your conviction," stated Bhavya Shah.

3. The 'Collar' (Funding Your Insurance)

Investors who have large, long-term profits often use a "Collar". This is a clever way to get insurance (the put) for free.

Here is how it works: they buy the protective put, but they pay for it by simultaneously selling a call option. The cash they get from selling the call pays for the put. This is often called a "zero-cost collar".

"There is no free lunch. By selling the call, the investor creates a ceiling. Their portfolio is now locked in a range. They are protected from all losses below the floor (the put), but they have also given up all profits above the ceiling (the call)," stated Bhavya Shah.

A Common Mistake: Thinking a 'Covered Call' is a Hedge

Many investors sell "Covered Calls" and think they are hedging. This is mostly an income strategy, not a protection strategy. Selling a call brings in a small premium, which can cover a tiny loss. But if the market crashes 20%, that small premium will not protect you.

When to Hedge? Using Signals, Not Feelings

The most successful investors don't hedge based on fear or feelings. They use clear, rules-based signals.

The India VIX: As we said, the VIX is key. The best time to buy insurance is when it is cheap. Investors are using the current low VIX (below 15) as a signal to buy protection before panic hits and the VIX spikes above 25 or 30.

The 200-Day Average: This is a famous, long-term trend signal. It is the average price of the Nifty over the last 200 days. If the Nifty breaks below this line, it is a major warning sign that the long-term trend is in trouble. This is a primary, non-emotional trigger to put hedges in place.

Trendline Breaks: This is a simple, visual signal. Investors draw a line connecting the recent lows of the market. If the market price breaks below this rising line, it is a signal that the upward momentum is broken and it might be time to protect your portfolio.

"The most successful investors I know treat risk management as a core part of their process. The key is to have a disciplined, rules-based approach. As technical analysts, we watch for signals of a break of the 200-day moving average, a major trendline violation. When these triggers hit, we don't 'hope', we execute. That is the difference between professional capital preservation and retail speculation," said Bhavya Shah, Technical Analyst, StoxBox.

Disclaimer: The views and recommendations expressed are solely those of the individual analysts or entities and do not reflect the views of GoodReturns.in or Greynium Information Technologies Private Limited (together referred as "we"). We do not guarantee, endorse or take responsibility for the accuracy, completeness or reliability of any content, nor do we provide any investment advice or solicit the purchase or sale of securities. All information is provided for informational and educational purposes only and should be independently verified from licensed financial advisors before making any investment decisions.